| Rank | Name | Alias | Song | Rating | Comments |
| 1 | Jacek Dojwa | Falcon | Goddess of fate | Outstanding | What can we say, a tremendous song. The musicality and intricacies are outstanding. It really tells a story - I pictured a thief entering a wealthy estate, starting to work his magic and then running into trouble :). Will be used for title music and promotional material. |
| 2 | Frej Bjon | Chotoro | Encounter with Mass Destruction | Outstanding | Epic tune. Perfect for a boss battle. The slow swooping melody in the brass goes very well with the staccato strings. Excellent job. |
| 3 | Bence Tasnadi | Nebidaan | Aurora Polaris | Outstanding | One word that kept being used to describe this song: Beautiful. Long flowing strings that are sometimes eerie. Excellent. Will be used for background to "sad" dialog. Reminds me of a Thomas Newman score. |
| 4 | David Pham Van | High Q | The Quest | Excellent | Exceptional song. Absolutely nails the "game music" feel we are after. We think this would fit well behind a desert theme, but could work for any of the realms. |
| 5 | Julien Nevo | | Kholdan | Excellent | Fantastic song, very majestic and inspiring. Would be good for a title screen. Starts slow and builds throughout, with excellent melody and pace. I imagine a group of adventurers equipping weapons and heading out to battle |
| 6 | Frej Bjon | Chotoro | Here we stand | Excellent | Lovely song. The chord that starts at 0:22 is beautiful. Has an almost Celtic feel. We plan to use this for "romantic" dialog. |
| 7 | Stefan Drakstal | | Deserted Heroes | Excellent | Really unique song here, another one that reminds us of Diablo 2. We really like the part from 2:30 onwards where it takes a more minor feel. Would be good for wandering catacombs. |
| 8 | oleg nikitin | n1k-o | desert of immortal empire | Excellent | Awesome song - really reminds us of Diablo 2. Perfect for the desert theme, this is great game music. Section that starts at 0:52 is very cool. |
| 9 | Juan Manuel Avila Ocana | juanma71 | Inmortal Menu | Excellent | We absolutely love the ending of this song. If we were to pick a "theme" for Immortal Empire, it would be the theme that is first introduced around 1:30. |
| 10 | Bence Tasnadi | Nebidaan | Slave Gemini | Great | Really epic song with the full chords and deep swells to the strings. Opening chord reminds me of Lord of the Rings. Would be good for the Polar realm we feel. |
| 11 | Carl Corcoran | tenfour | Polar theme No. 1 | Great | Nice bright and crisp samples used right at the start here. We actually feel this fits the Grasslands realm. Great for a bunch of adventurers wandering a landscape :). This song really grows as it progresses, some excellent sections towards the end of the track. |
| 12 | Steve Williams | Eyspire | Untold Fable | Great | Really nice tune. Love the part where the piano comes in at 1:01. The melody is very memorable, I find myself humming it after the song is done. This is one that you can listen to over and over. Great for a grasslands/town theme. |
| 13 | Nick Williams | skyscape | Conquests | Great | Nice song, would be good for some tense dialog. |
| 14 | Steve Williams | Eyspire | Sand-swept Horizon | Great | Another great desert tune. Absolutely the right pace for game music. The pizzicato strings that show up at 0:40 and appear at certain places throughout are a really nice touch. |
| 15 | juha vilmi | jv | 7 | Great | Really beautiful musically. Excellent chord progressions, and a nice melody. Peaceful and would be nice dialog music. The only recommendation I would make would be to put more volume inflection through the broken triads at the very start to improve the phrasing. |
| 16 | Steve Williams | Eyspire | The Fray Chambers | Great | The main melody that goes from 0:35 through to 0:50 is the really great part of this tune. Some of the sections such at the part from 0:05 to 0:15 have an almost "silly" feel that doesn't seem in line with the rest of the track. |
| 17 | Nick Williams | skyscape | Black Ice | Great | Very quiet and mysterious. Excellent for Volcanic realm. The industrial drum section that comes in at 3:30 is really great, reminds us of Diablo 2. Would be awesome to hear that part expanded. |
| 18 | juha vilmi | jv | morko | Very Good | Nice tune. We really like the chord progressions from 1:15 forward to 1:40. Parts are great for a boss battle, others are more peaceful. Perhaps good for general "battle" music. |
| 19 | Marc Verchiani | Arboreal | Septentrional | Very Good | A perfect fit for menu music. Peaceful, quiet, yet still interesting. Would go well for a "building" game like civilization too. |
| 20 | Andrej Kwadrin | nazzard | First Light | Very Good | We really like the "futuristic" sound. One of the few entries that went with the "Mass Effect" feel. We think this fits well into the polar realm. |
| 21 | Niko Koivisto | aged | forgiven | Very Good | Great drums and strings. We thought the section between 0:30 through 1:30 really stood out. |
| 22 | Chris Crescendo | Denim | No Return. 2x Loops | Very Good | Great tune for a boss battle. We really liked the part when the chanting choir comes in at 00:51. |
| 23 | Nick Williams | skyscape | Journey Over Golden Sands | Very Good | Definitely good for a desert realm. Has the right pace for in-game music. |
| 24 | Bence Tasnadi | Nebidaan | Opalcyclops | Very Good | Another great boss battle song. Really like the chord progressions that start at around 00:50, very eerie. Would suggest a more thunderous percussion, perhaps timpani, at the climax part around 1:35 |
| 25 | Julien Jolly | Solion | Fire Land | Good | Nicely paced tune that keeps the intensity throughout. We really liked the section at 2:30 onwards. |
| 26 | David Cummings | Agargara | Wandering Sands | Good | Nice song, slow paced and would be good for a desert theme |
| 27 | Cody Loyd | mrcold | volcano | Good | Awesome string bass sample right off the bat. Very intense tune. Good for introduction of an evil character. |
| 28 | Nick Williams | skyscape | Blood and Steel | Good | Good choir and a nice listen, not sure about the percussion though. I think a more traditional orchestral timpani/bass drum/snare would suit the music better than the rhythmic drums. |
| 29 | Jonathan Dupre | Blackbean | A narrow cleft | Good | Great fit for the Volcanic realm. Evil, dark, smoky, barren. |
| 30 | Fabio Napodano | It-Alien | Flames | Good | Very intense tune. The part that starts at 1:30 is really good. Bass line that comes in at 1:48 would make for a great boss battle riff. The woodwinds that come in at 2:05 and 2:36 are overwhelming. Would be good for a "descent into madness" sensation. |
| 31 | Fabio Napodano | It-Alien | Dance of Fallen Angels | Good | Love the fugue-esque start to this song. Almost too elaborate for game music, this really tells a story. Would be good for cinematics. |
| 32 | Nick Williams | skyscape | The Ethereal | Good | The start of this is really interesting - ethereal describes it exactly. Very quiet and paced throughout. The ending seems a bit out of place. |
| 33 | Fabio Napodano | It-Alien | Entering Hell's Doors | Good | This has the feeling of a movement out of an entire symphony. Would be cool for a trailer or cinematic. |
| 34 | Daniel Akerud | | Trollen Kommer | Fair | Very cute short tune. We picture a bunch of mischievous goblins stealing vegetables from some unsuspecting farmer :) |
| 35 | Fabio Napodano | It-Alien | Passage | Fair | First thing that comes to mind with this one is the TV show Lost. Your music would be great incidental background to an opera or play. |
| 36 | Nick Williams | skyscape | The March | Fair | Another situation where I don't think the percussion suits the music. Has a sort of Spanish rhythm section feel backing some very epic chords. |
| 37 | Steve Williams | Eyspire | The Embarkment | Fair | Sounds like it should be behind a man standing on a podium giving an inspiring speech :). Nice progressions. Does not really fit for game music however. |
| 38 | lenny seven | p7 | untitled | Fair | We like the lower mellow tone and the airy pads, but the higher bell sound is almost too detuned. Nice pace overall. |
| 39 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Zow | Fair | Good deep chords, but I think this suffers from lack of melody and progression. |
| 40 | Dac Chartrand | Beer Wife | A nice touch for a goth wedding | Fair | Musically this is very pretty, but it is not helped by the samples. I don't think the contrast of the bright strings fit well with the mellow electric piano sound. The chord progressions are nice and the melody is very memorable :). |
| 41 | lenny seven | p7 | untitled | Fair | Would be neat background music, but seems almost too disjointed in sections. |
| 42 | Jason Mosack | | Artic Wanderer | Fair | Very slow song, the piano sample sounds slightly detuned, we think a mellow piano sound perhaps an octave lower would go better here. The chord progression that is reached at 0:16 does not flow as smoothly as the others. |
| 43 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Heet Boven for synth | Fair | Very traditional sounding, definitely needs a melody and some more inflection of volume throughout to give it more phrasing. |
| 44 | Marco Kittel | | Butterflyeffect | Wrong Style | Cool tune, but not the right style for this competition. |
| 45 | michael callesen | Scandinavian Noize Syndicate | entering a dark and cold world | Wrong Style | Not the right style for this competition. |
| 46 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | TL User | Wrong Style | We had fun rocking out to all your techno songs! Unfortunately it doesn't suit the style of the competition :). |
| 47 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Part 7 - Version 2 | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 48 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | At Celes | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 49 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | This One | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 50 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Spaceway | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 51 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Spacezapper | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 52 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Thanks | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 53 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Candybar | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 54 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | Ash | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
| 55 | EatMe paashaas.da.ru | EatMe | More or less for Christmas | Wrong Style | Doesn't suit style of competition. |
